James Stewart

"Fish and chips hit the spot. More expensive than it should be, but come on, you’re in Nantucket."

"Had the fish and chips (above average) and fish tacos (excellent). Recommend the local hot sauce (mix it with tartar sauce with fish and chips!). Very casual but enjoyed. Slow service on quiet night."

"Walk the extra few blocks to David's, please."

"Great breakfast sandwiches"

"Smelled like subway. So great experience."

"No TVs...I guess it's the type of bar where you're meant to talk to people."